An overstuffed bauble of mystery. The Honey Pot plays like a Victorian whodunit, except it was sent on a Venetian vacation and told to luxuriate.
Rex Harrison stars as Cecil Fox—an old money eccentric with an army of servants, too much time on his hands, and one very strange idea. He will fake his death just to watch his three ex-lovers squirm over inheritance. The setup is cribbed from the 17th Century Ben Jonson play Volpone. Except here, with the genders flipped, the satire thinned, and tension replaced by a kind of mannered mischief with a high thread count.
The guests arrive to his abode like characters who have barged in from competing movies. Dominique (Capucine) is a broke princess with an icy restraint. Merle (Edie Adams) is a fading screen star who is still chasing the spotlight. And then Lone Star Crockett (Susan Hayward), a Texan tycoon with a load of paperwork and tongue sharp enough to draw blood.
Lone Star claims to be Fox’s common-law wife and she can prove it. But before she gets much further staking her claim, she ends up dead. Enter Maggie Smith as her nurse. She’s prim and observant and also slowly realizing that she’s the only one in the room who possesses either a conscience or a clue.
The pleasure here resides mainly in the details. The rustle of expensive fabrics, the glint of chandeliers. Rex Harrison literally pirouettes through the margins of the story as though he’s auditioning for operetta. But in spite of the solid setup and a solid cast, the core mystery ends up folding in on itself. Such that when the resolution finally arrives, it feels like it’s all beside the point. Not so much a mystery solved as a thread that gets obligatorily tied up and then set aside in favor of something more opaque and metaphysical.
A movie that mistakes convolution for cleverness and mood for meaning. Still, a worthwhile watch for anyone interested in immersing themselves with the crisp performances of the actors. In particular that of Maggie Smith who, despite only really entering the film halfway through, ends up walking away with the whole movie tucked neatly in her handbag.